My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I’m a big fan of seamless knitting, especially top down knitting, & I’m definitely a Barbara Walker fan as well. I got this book out of the library after seeing some of the projects people made on Ravelry, because I’ve been itching for a new top down project.
There are some gorgeous, but impractical projects in the book – Jill’s dress comes immediately to mind.
(photo found via Ravelry)
I love the simple, classic lines, one color, in a multitude of sizes from 32″ to 51″ (finished measurements). But… the fact remains, how many people are going to actually knit a dress, at 5 sts/inch, using a beautiful, but expensive yarn? As a knitter, I definitely know that it’s more often about the process then the finished object, but in the case of a dress… I do think it’s going to be a lot about the finished object. A quick google search yields me an average price of $9/skein – which isn’t too bad, really, but you need 10 skeins for the smallest size, yielding a dress of $90. In my size, however, that quickly jumps to almost $110. Of course you can always sub yarns, but this is a dress after all… Considering I buy my dresses at the thrift store, I won’t be making this anytime soon, no matter how gorgeous I think it is.
I also really like the Blueberry Cardigan, that calls for Blue Sky Alpaca Silk, that averages $13/skein. I love the stitches used in this, but I’d personally mod the cardigan so much, my finished object would bear little with the original.
Looking for a smaller project? There’s a cute hat, Mulberry Hat, that I really like…
but there are a dozen very similiar, free hats available online (ditto the Pigeon hat). In fact, you can get the Mulberry Hat as a free download
My conclusion? If this technique is new to you &/or you don’t have any other top down books in your library, then it’s definitely worth buying for the infomation, but if you are already familiar with top down knitting… get the book from the library.